THE 20 BEST Pizza Restaurants in Mechanicsburg, PA - 2024 Restaurantji (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“Giuseppe's Pizza Cantina is a restaurant known for its delicious upside-down pizza and kind staff. In addition to pizza, they offer cheesesteak sandwiches, wraps, and salads, all highly regarded by customers. The grilled chicken salad and fries are particularly noteworthy. One customer even travels 45 minutes from Duncannon just to enjoy their New York-style pizza, praising its consistent flavor. The restaurant is also recognized for its garlic butter dip and the polite teen who takes orders.“

Customers` Favorites

“Amici Pizza is a highly-recommended spot in the Harrisburg/Mechanicsburg area. The moment you step inside, you'll be greeted by a clean and nicely decorated atmosphere. The staff is prompt and friendly, with a focus on providing excellent service. The pizzas are a standout, with a unique balance of flavors and a crust that's closer to New York-style than traditional Midwest hand-toss. The sauce and toppings are top-notch, with options like sausage, broccoli, and chicken. The restaurant also offers a variety of other menu items, including chicken fingers, fries, breadsticks, Caesar salad, baked ziti, eggplant parm, and strombolis. Amici Pizza is a great choice for both takeout and catering, with accommodating staff and delicious food. They go above and beyond to tailor to customers' needs, whether it's a special request or a last-minute change.“

Customers` Favorites

“Pizzatown USA, located in a strip mall on Simpson Ferry Road, offers a variety of pizza options including pepperoni, cheese fries, and a delicious stuffed pizza. The restaurant has a friendly and accommodating staff, with gluten-free and vegetarian options available. The establishment, while showing some wear on the inside, has a clean environment. The Sicilian pizza is a must-try, with its light and crispy crust. Prices are reasonable and service is excellent, making it a great choice for satisfying your pizza cravings.“

Customers` Favorites

“Sal's Pizza is a great place for lunch, offering huge single slices of pizza. The staff is nice, and the prices are reasonable. With a variety of options on the menu, it never disappoints, providing the best pizza and food around. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming, reminiscent of a place in Italy. Wheelchair accessibility is good, and parking is convenient as soon as you enter. A 5-star experience in every category, definitely worth a visit.“

Customers` Favorites

“Little Mario's Pizza is a delightful restaurant offering delicious pizza and a cozy atmosphere. Known for its crispy crust, gooey cheese, and generous portions, it is a popular choice for pizza lovers. The meat lovers pizza and homemade-tasting sauce are especially noteworthy. Whether you're a local or visiting from out of town, Little Mario's Pizza is a hidden gem worth trying.“

Customers` Favorites

“JoJo's Pizza & Pasta Main Street is a popular spot for delicious meals. Their pizza is a hit, especially for those from New York. The restaurant is accommodating for both small and large groups, with off-street parking and plenty of seating. The staff is helpful, and the atmosphere is family-friendly, with a game area for kids. Prices are average, and the decor is pleasing.“

Customers` Favorites

“Pizza Boli's is a highly recommended restaurant for pizza and more. Known for its out-of-this-world pizzas, the crust is soft and doughy with perfectly melted and gooey cheese. A wide range of toppings ensures something for everyone. Portions are generous, providing great value.Their customer service is commendable, with staff going above and beyond to rectify any issues. In addition to their excellent pizzas, Pizza Boli's also offers highly rated cheeseburger subs, wings, and cheesy bread.For over a year, families and individuals have chosen Pizza Boli's over other pizza places, impressed by the consistent quality and care for their customers. It is the go-to place for pizza and subs, offering an exceptional dining experience.“

Customers` Favorites

“JoJo's Pizza & Pasta Upper Allen is a fantastic place that accommodates dietary restrictions with gluten-free options like gluten-free rolls, pizza, penne, and ravioli. The restaurant offers quick service, delicious food, and plenty of seating for couples, large groups, and even has a banquet area. The menu features a variety of options, including penne with meat sauce and meatballs, which comes with a salad and bread. The atmosphere is nice, and the restaurant has a wide open parking lot with wheelchair-accessible spaces near the door.“

Customers` Favorites

“Santucci's Pizza Mechanicsburg offers a delicious experience with their amazing pizza and cheesesteak Stromboli. The sauce on the pizza is reminiscent of boardwalk and beaches in Jersey. The crust is light and airy, making it a must-try. Customers appreciate the improved food quality since the opening, making it one of the best pizza places they've ever been to. Outstanding service and a clean atmosphere complete the great experience at Santucci's.“

Customers` Favorites

“Vito's Pizza is a family-run business serving the best pizza in the state. This cozy restaurant offers a welcoming environment with loyal customers enjoying delicious food. The pizza features New York-style dough and excellent sauce. The staff is kind, accommodating, and attentive to requests. Recommended are the lunch specials, which offer quality food at a great price. The menu also includes tasty subs, wraps, and salads. This kid-friendly restaurant is a great place to bring friends and family for a satisfying meal.“

Customers` Favorites

“Amore Pizza Arcona is a welcoming spot with a small-town feel. The staff is kind and goes above and beyond. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere, with quaint tables to sit and enjoy a meal. The menu offers delicious options, including the popular margherita pizza, and a great-tasting tiramisu for dessert. Despite being a bit pricey, this spot is a great place to grab a quality bite to eat.“

Customers` Favorites

“Oscar's Pizza Town USA is a must-visit restaurant with delicious food and great prices. Customers love the friendly atmosphere and helpful staff who ensure you get value for money. Whether you're craving a turkey and cheese sub or a mouthwatering pizza like sausage and onion, this place delivers. With quick service and perfect meals, it's no wonder this spot is a favorite in the area.“

Customers` Favorites

“Home Slice Pizza is a popular spot known for its delicious New York-style pizza. The "OG pizza," cooked well-done, and the "Grandpa (crispy)" pizza are favorites, featuring flavorful tomato sauce and a crispy crust that remains so even when taken out. The cheesesteak is another recommended dish. The staff is friendly, and the store is clean with ample parking available. Although the seating might be a bit tight for wheelchairs, there is a ramp at the front door for accessibility. A small gelato station has recently opened inside, adding to the menu's appeal.“

Customers` Favorites

“Massimo's Italian Bakery is a must-visit destination for dessert lovers. The owner and staff are welcoming and helpful, offering samples of their delicious, authentic, and fresh treats. The bakery is stocked with a wide variety of tempting pastries, gelato, cakes, and cannoli. Be sure to try the pastry with chocolate mousse and Reese's buttercups, and don't miss their amazing chicken Parmesan. With its beautiful atmosphere and exceptional service, Massimo's is a place you'll want to return to again and again.“

Customers` Favorites

“Marzoni's Brick Oven & Brewing Co. is a welcoming restaurant with friendly and attentive staff. The bartender/servers provide efficient service and are happy to listen to customers' concerns. The food is a highlight, with a variety of options including pizzas, pasta dishes, and sandwiches. The mango habañero pizza and Cajun pasta are standouts, while the pizza is a must-try with many options to choose from. Although some dishes may be hit or miss, the portions are generous and the prices are reasonable. With a family-friendly layout and open area, Marzoni's is a great spot for a meal with kids.“

Customers` Favorites

“Heat Restaurant Lounge is a new addition to the Mechanicsburg area, offering a variety of foods from soul food to international options. Standout dishes include fried chicken, buffalo shrimp, brick oven wings, turkey wings, and smoked wings. The restaurant also serves salmon fried rice and offers a pizza shop-like atmosphere. Customers can expect delicious and flavorful meals, friendly service, and a clean environment. Many recommend trying the establishment's breakfast as well.“

Customers` Favorites

“Italian Delight Pizzeria is a welcoming establishment that serves delicious and flavorful food. Upon entering, guests are greeted by the aroma of fresh ingredients and pizza straight out of the oven. The restaurant offers a range of options, including gluten-free choices. The pizza crust is perfect, with smooth Italian sauce and melted cheese. The owners, Sal and Lucia, provide excellent service, making customers feel like family. Other menu items, such as lasagna and cheesesteaks, are also highly praised. With large portions and reasonable prices, Italian Delight Pizzeria is a great spot for a family dinner or a casual night out.“

Customers` Favorites

“Palumbo Pizza is a restaurant known for its consistent and delicious food. Their grandma pizza is a popular choice, described as huge and reasonably priced. Other menu items, such as their saucy wings, cheeseburger sub, and tuna sub, have also received positive feedback. For those who enjoy spice, their pizza with onions and banana peppers is a recommended choice. The restaurant also offers fresh rolls and quick delivery.“

Customers` Favorites

“Little Caesars Pizza offers tasty food, although there have been instances where the breadsticks were undercooked. The absence of dine-in options means that seating is only available in your vehicle, and the small parking lot can be crowded, but it's usually possible to find a spot. Pre-ordering is recommended to avoid waiting in the small front area. Vegetarian options are limited to pizza with various toppings. A notable change is that red sauce cups are no longer available for trade in favor of garlic butter.“

Customers` Favorites

“Domino's Pizza is a reliable and customer-friendly restaurant. The staff is friendly, and the orders are delivered quickly and accurately. The menu offers a variety of options, including pan pizza, feta-spinach crazy bread, pastas, chicken dishes, and a delicious Mediterranean veggie sandwich. Customers have consistently positive experiences with the restaurant.“